Cheshire East Council: High Court Refuses to Discharge Interim Care Orders

The High Court has refused to discharge interim care orders in a case involving two children whose family had been living at Webb House in Crewe. The decision highlights the court’s approach to interim child-protection measures where the allegations are serious, the police investigation is ongoing and the available evidence has not yet been fully disclosed.

What did the High Court decide?

In Cheshire East Borough Council v M and Others (Discharge of Interim Care Orders) [2026] EWHC 1606 (Fam), Mr Justice Hayden refused the application to discharge the interim care orders concerning T and A. The judgment was handed down on 26 June 2026 in the Family Division of the High Court.

The orders had been made on 12 May 2026. The application to discharge them was brought while a large-scale police investigation was continuing. The judge concluded that there had not been any significant development capable of providing a proper basis to reassess the risks to the children. On the evidence then available, the protective arrangements remained justified.

The decision did not determine whether the allegations under investigation were true. The court was considering whether interim safeguards should remain in place while the evidence was gathered and tested.

What led to the care proceedings?

The judgment records that Cheshire Police carried out searches at three addresses on 29 April 2026, including Webb House. More than 100 adults and children were said to have been living at Webb House, with other members of the community attending the property while living elsewhere.

Information shared with Cheshire East Borough Council raised allegations of sexual abuse, modern slavery, human trafficking, violence, neglect, forced or underage marriage and other concerns about children’s welfare. The judgment also records concerns relating to living conditions, education and access to medical care. These matters were described as allegations and intelligence under investigation, rather than findings made after a final hearing.

Following the police operation, the local authority supported families in finding temporary accommodation or arranging alternative living arrangements. Cheshire Police advised that children should not return to Webb House, and the local authority did not support their return while the investigation continued.

The proceedings involved 41 children across linked cases. Interim orders had been made in respect of those children. In the case before Hayden J, T and A were living with a parent or family members rather than in local-authority foster care.

Why were the interim care orders maintained?

The judge considered that the risks identified in the information supplied by the police remained serious and had not yet been sufficiently clarified. The evidence available to the local authority and the court was limited, police disclosure was incomplete, and some Achieving Best Evidence interviews with children were still ongoing.

Mr Justice Hayden rejected the argument that the interim care orders should be discharged because the parents disputed the allegations and wished to return to Webb House. He emphasised that the central question was the potential harm to the children, not whether communal living or religious belief was itself harmful. The judgment expressly distinguished the allegations of criminality and harm from the family’s religious or communal way of life.

The judge also noted that the orders were being used in a limited way: the children remained with a parent or within their extended families in the overwhelming majority of cases. The local authority shared parental responsibility, providing a protective framework while the investigation proceeded.

“The criteria remain just as exacting”

The judgment explains that the interim-stage exercise focuses on whether there are reasonable grounds to believe the statutory criteria are met, rather than requiring the court to make final findings at that stage.

The judge concluded that discharging the orders at that point would remove an important protective safeguard while the serious allegations remained under investigation. He therefore considered the orders necessary and proportionate.

What does the ruling mean for care proceedings?

The decision underlines that an application to discharge an interim care order must engage with the child’s welfare and the continuing need for protection. Simply disputing the allegations does not, by itself, establish that the interim safeguards are no longer required.

The court also made clear that further applications should not be issued without a proper basis. Where a family considers that particular circumstances genuinely call into question the continuing need for an interim order, an application may be made in writing. If it is arguable, it can be listed for an oral hearing. The judge warned against applications that needlessly consume time, cause delay or distract from the investigation.

For local authorities and practitioners, the judgment illustrates the importance of keeping interim measures under review, ensuring that they remain proportionate, and maintaining a clear focus on the identified risks to the children. It also demonstrates that the court may preserve temporary safeguards while the evidential position develops, without treating allegations as proven facts.

Finally, the anonymity direction is essential. The judgment was delivered in private and publication is permitted only on the strict condition that the identities of the children and family members are protected. Any reporting or republication must comply with that restriction.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Frequently asked questions

What did the High Court decide in this case?

Mr Justice Hayden refused the application to discharge the interim care orders concerning T and A. The court considered that the orders remained necessary and proportionate while the police investigation and evidence-gathering continued.

Were the allegations against the adults proved?

No. The judgment addressed an interim application and repeatedly recognised that the evidence was incomplete and the allegations remained under investigation. It did not make final findings that the alleged conduct had occurred.

Were the children placed in foster care?

In this case, the children remained with a parent or within their extended family. The interim care orders enabled the local authority to share parental responsibility while protective arrangements remained in place.

What is the threshold for an interim care order?

Under section 38(2) of the Children Act 1989, the court must be satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the circumstances in section 31(2) exist, including that the child is suffering or is likely to suffer significant harm.

Can a parent apply to discharge an interim care order?

Yes. The judgment indicates that an application may be made in writing where particular circumstances genuinely call into question the continuing need for the order. If the application is arguable, it may be listed for an oral hearing.

Why must the children remain anonymous?

The judgment was delivered in private and publication was authorised on the strict condition that the anonymity of the children and their family members be preserved. Breaching that condition may amount to contempt of court.

Don’t Miss Key Legal Updates

Get SRA rule changes, SDT decisions, and legal industry news straight to your inbox.
Latest news
Related news