The Youth Justice Board (YJB) has backed government proposals aimed at changing how childhood criminal records are disclosed to employers and education providers, arguing that young people who have moved away from offending should not face unnecessary barriers to rebuilding their lives.
What has the Youth Justice Board welcomed?
In an announcement published on 13 November 2026, the YJB welcomed the Ministry of Justice’s launch of a consultation on targeted reform of childhood criminal records disclosure. The Board said it had long advocated changes intended to give children a fairer opportunity to move forward after contact with the justice system.
YJB Chief Executive Stephanie Roberts-Bibby said children are still developing and that many who come into contact with the justice system go on to change their lives. She warned that continued disclosure of a childhood record can restrict access to education, employment and other opportunities that support rehabilitation.
The Board also recognised the importance of criminal record checks in protecting the public. Its support is for a more proportionate approach that allows those who have turned their lives around to progress while retaining safeguards for victims, communities and vulnerable people.
Why is the government proposing reform?
The Ministry of Justice says the current disclosure regime can leave some childhood convictions visible for life, including where a person has not offended again for many years. The government considers that this can create lasting obstacles to employment, education, training and volunteering, potentially undermining rehabilitation.
The consultation notes that a criminal record was the second most frequently cited barrier to hiring people from disadvantaged groups in Department for Work and Pensions analysis published in 2024, with 47% of employers identifying it as a barrier. It also refers to evidence that many people first convicted as children do not continue offending persistently into adulthood.
The proposals seek to balance rehabilitation with public protection. The government says lifelong disclosure would remain for the most serious offences, including serious violent, sexual and terrorism-related offences. It is not proposing changes to the Disclosure and Barring Service barring scheme.
What are the five proposed changes?
The consultation sets out five areas for potential reform. Each would require legislative change if the government decides to proceed.
- Create a narrower list of specified offences for childhood convictions. This would distinguish certain childhood offences from the list that currently prevents convictions from being filtered off standard and enhanced checks.
- End lifelong disclosure on standard and enhanced checks for childhood convictions resulting in custodial sentences of two years or less, where the offence is not on the proposed specified-offences list. The consultation proposes an 11-year disclosure period for qualifying convictions.
- Reduce the rehabilitation period for childhood convictions resulting in a fine from six months to three months, or consider making the conviction spent immediately.
- Remove the automatic disclosure requirement for childhood out-of-court resolutions, including statutory and non-statutory resolutions.
- Remove the “drag-on” rule for childhood convictions, so a later childhood conviction would not automatically extend the rehabilitation period of an earlier childhood conviction.
The proposals are designed to reduce the number of childhood records disclosed for life while preserving disclosure requirements for serious offences and the safeguarding information needed for relevant roles.
How would the proposals affect disclosure?
The consultation distinguishes between basic checks and standard or enhanced checks. Basic checks generally disclose unspent convictions and cautions and may be used for a wide range of roles. Standard and enhanced checks are available only for eligible roles that require fuller criminal record information, with enhanced checks also allowing relevant local police information to be considered.
| Area | Current position described in the consultation | Proposed change |
|---|---|---|
| Specified offences | Childhood convictions for specified offences can remain disclosed for life on standard and enhanced checks. | A narrower specified-offences list would apply to childhood convictions, while serious offences would remain subject to lifelong disclosure. |
| Short custodial sentences | Childhood convictions resulting in a custodial sentence are generally disclosed for life on standard and enhanced checks. | Qualifying non-specified convictions with sentences of two years or less could be filtered after a proposed 11-year period. |
| Fines | A childhood conviction resulting in a fine has a six-month rehabilitation period for basic disclosure. | The period could fall to three months or the fine could become spent immediately. |
| Out-of-court resolutions | A youth conditional caution is currently disclosed until it becomes spent. | Automatic disclosure of any childhood out-of-court resolution could end. |
| Drag-on rule | A later conviction before an earlier one becomes spent can extend the rehabilitation period. | The rule would no longer apply between childhood convictions in the way proposed by the consultation. |
The consultation provides figures showing that childhood offences account for a small proportion of standard and enhanced DBS certificates. Between November 2023 and April 2026, 0.71% of standard certificates and 0.35% of enhanced certificates issued disclosed childhood offences, according to the Ministry of Justice document.
The government says the proposals would not remove lifelong disclosure for the most serious offences and would not alter the DBS barring scheme, which is intended to prevent people who pose a risk from working with children or vulnerable adults.
What happens next?
The consultation opened on 12 November 2026 and is due to close on 24 December 2026. The Ministry of Justice is inviting responses from people affected by childhood criminal record disclosure, youth justice organisations, employers, safeguarding bodies and organisations that use criminal record checks in recruitment or licensing decisions.
Responses can be submitted through the Ministry of Justice’s online consultation. The department will consider the feedback before deciding whether to take the proposals forward. Any reforms would require legislative changes when parliamentary time allows; the consultation does not itself change the current disclosure rules.
For legal professionals advising employers, applicants or organisations that rely on DBS checks, the proposals are an important development to monitor. Until any legislation is introduced and comes into force, existing disclosure and filtering requirements continue to apply.
Frequently asked questions
Have childhood criminal record disclosure rules already changed?
No. The Ministry of Justice has launched a consultation on proposed reforms. The current rules remain in force unless and until legislation is passed and implemented.
When does the consultation close?
The consultation opened on 12 November 2026 and closes on 24 December 2026.
Will serious childhood offences still be disclosed?
The proposals intend to retain lifelong disclosure for the most serious offences, including serious violent, sexual and terrorism-related offences. The consultation proposes a narrower specified-offences list for childhood convictions, not the removal of all lifelong disclosure.
Would the proposals change the DBS barring scheme?
No. The consultation expressly states that it is not proposing changes to the Disclosure and Barring Service barring scheme.
Who can respond to the consultation?
Responses are invited from anyone affected by having to disclose a youth criminal record, youth justice and criminal records organisations, employers, safeguarding organisations and other interested members of the public.