President of the Family Division Calls for Children’s Voices to Be Heard in Family Justice

President of the Family Division calls for children’s voices to be central to family justice
  • Children affected by family separation 280,000 Across England and Wales
  • Children in Family Court proceedings 80,000+ Public and private law cases
  • Child-inclusive mediation 16% Relevant cases involving children over ten

The President of the Family Division has called for a stronger culture of children’s participation in family justice, arguing that children must be treated as individuals whose experiences and views should inform decisions about their lives.

What did the President of the Family Division say?

In a keynote address to the West Midlands Law Society on 12 November 2026, the President of the Family Division addressed the importance of involving children in decisions arising from family separation. The speech, published by the Courts and Tribunals Judiciary, considers when children should be heard, how participation should be achieved and why it matters.

The address begins by highlighting the scale of family separation across England and Wales. Approximately 280,000 children and young people are affected, with more than 80,000 involved in proceedings before the Family Courts. These figures include children living between two homes while parents dispute arrangements, as well as children whose future care is being determined.

The President cautions against viewing these figures simply as caseloads, applications or files. Each figure represents a child experiencing uncertainty, and potentially conflict, neglect, abuse or loss. The speech argues that family justice is ultimately about decisions that may shape children’s lives for years or even generations.

It also emphasises that the welfare principle must be applied individually. Children cannot be assessed through general categories or stereotypes; their circumstances, experiences, vulnerabilities and strengths must be considered.

When should children be heard?

The President argues that children’s participation should be considered throughout the entire journey of family separation. It should not begin only when proceedings reach court, when Cafcass becomes involved or when a judge considers meeting a child. Instead, participation should start at the earliest possible stage and continue after litigation or dispute resolution has ended.

Many decisions affecting children are initially made at home, during conversations between parents who are themselves dealing with the emotional pressures of separation. The speech challenges the traditional approach of keeping children entirely away from such discussions. Children often recognise that something is changing, notice tension and fill gaps in information with their own assumptions. Adults should help them understand what is happening in a safe and age-appropriate way.

Parents have the primary responsibility for enabling participation, but separation can place them under considerable emotional pressure. Wider family networks, schools, Early Help services, family therapists and Family Group Decision Making processes can also play an important role.

The address also points to a gap between professional aspiration and current practice. A 2025 Family Mediation Council survey found that child-inclusive mediation took place in only around 16 per cent of relevant cases involving children over ten. The President suggests that the barrier is often cultural rather than a lack of professional capability: some practitioners treat children’s participation as routine, while others continue to regard it as exceptional.

Within the Family Court, the Child Focused Court model is intended to bring children’s experiences closer to the centre of proceedings. Early Child Impact Reports may help decision-makers understand a child’s perspective, including through a photograph and, in some cases, a direct message for the judge. The speech notes that child-focused justice is also associated with reduced time between application and final decision.

“Participation without feedback is incomplete participation.”

Participation should not end when a decision is made. Children need to understand what was decided, why it was decided and what happens next. The speech draws on Professor Laura Lundy’s model, which identifies four elements of participation: space, voice, audience and influence. Children need a safe opportunity to express their views, support to communicate them, an audience willing to listen and evidence that their views have been considered.

How should participation work?

The speech stresses that children are not a homogeneous group. A 17-year-old may wish to participate in a very different way from a seven-year-old, while children with communication difficulties may need different methods of support. Participation should therefore be tailored, proportionate and responsive to each child’s needs.

The President warns against tokenism. Asking a child a question and then ignoring the answer is not meaningful participation. Nor is consulting a child without explaining the process or offering opportunities that feel intimidating, inaccessible or irrelevant.

Professionals should also use language children can understand. The Family Justice Young People’s Board has previously highlighted the difficulty of legal acronyms and terminology. Children should be addressed by their names, rather than treated as case numbers, and given opportunities to express themselves at different stages of the process.

The speech recognises Cafcass practitioners’ experience in helping children communicate safely and effectively. It also considers judicial engagement. Judges may meet children to understand their experiences, but such meetings are not evidence-gathering exercises or informal cross-examinations. They must not transfer responsibility for the decision to the child. The Court of Appeal’s decision in Re KP [2014] EWCA Civ 554 is cited as a reminder that a judge must remain largely a passive recipient of the communication the child wishes to provide.

Judicial letters can also help children understand decisions affecting them. The speech refers to Re A (Letter to a Young Person) [2017] EWFC 48 and more recent examples of family judges communicating decisions directly to children.

It also questions whether paper-based and text-heavy systems reflect how young people communicate today. The President notes that some young people subject to deprivation of liberty orders have used platforms such as TikTok to describe their experiences. These forms of expression raise questions about whether family justice processes offer children meaningful ways to communicate in a digitally integrated world.

Why does child participation matter?

Family separation is a significant transition, although it does not inevitably lead to poor outcomes. The speech identifies prolonged conflict, uncertainty and exclusion from important decisions as factors that can have lasting consequences for children’s wellbeing and development.

The Family Solutions Group report What About Me? is cited for the benefits of hearing children’s voices. Children who feel listened to may have a better understanding of what is happening, greater resilience and a stronger sense of respect. Child-inclusive processes are also associated with improved parental cooperation and more durable agreements.

Children may provide adults with information that would otherwise remain unknown. Their ability to express their experiences, wishes and feelings can help professionals and parents understand the effect of decisions on their lives.

However, participation does not mean asking children to make decisions that belong to adults. The President draws a clear distinction between listening to a child and doing whatever the child wants. Adults remain responsible for decisions; a child’s perspective should inform the outcome, but does not necessarily determine it.

The speech also places participation within a rights-based framework. Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child recognises every child’s right to express views in matters affecting them, with those views given due weight according to age and maturity. The right is not limited to older teenagers.

What changes are proposed for 2027?

The President identifies several developments in family justice, including the Families First Partnership programme, Family Group Decision Making and Child Focused Courts. These reforms share an aim of placing children’s experiences more firmly at the centre of decision-making.

The speech says the forthcoming review of the 2015 Voice of the Child Advisory Group’s work should provide renewed impetus and practical recommendations. Revised guidance on judges meeting children is also expected to encourage discussion across the Family Court.

As Head of Family Justice, the President proposes treating 2027 as the year of Children’s Participation. The address also calls for greater accountability and better national data. At present, there is limited routine information about how often judges meet children, how frequently judicial letters are sent or how children engage in child-focused court processes.

The President argues that progress should be measured and made transparent so that improvements can be evaluated and gaps identified. The speech concludes that courts cannot remove all the pain or conflict associated with family separation, nor can they always deliver the outcome a child hopes for. They can, however, listen, explain and involve children in processes that profoundly affect their lives.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Frequently asked questions

What is children’s participation in family justice?

It means giving children safe, appropriate and meaningful opportunities to express their experiences, wishes and feelings in decisions affecting their lives, and ensuring that their views are genuinely considered.

Does a child get to make the final decision?

No. The speech makes clear that adults remain responsible for decisions. A child’s perspective should inform the decision, but it does not necessarily determine the outcome.

When should children be involved in family separation decisions?

The President says participation should begin at the earliest possible stage and continue throughout the process, including after court proceedings or dispute resolution have ended.

What is the proposed year of Children’s Participation?

The President of the Family Division has proposed treating 2027 as the year of Children’s Participation, with a focus on strengthening practice, reviewing guidance and improving accountability.

What does Article 12 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child provide?

It recognises every child’s right to express views in matters affecting them and to have those views given due weight according to their age and maturity.

Don’t Miss Key Legal Updates

Get SRA rule changes, SDT decisions, and legal industry news straight to your inbox.
Latest news
Related news