Replay Destinations Wins Privy Council Appeal Over US$774,590 Deposit Dispute

A party to a property development contract may be able to terminate for the other party’s breach even where it has also failed to perform its own obligations, the Privy Council has ruled in Replay Destinations (Bahamas) Ltd v Royal Ltd and another (Bahamas) [2026] UKPC 42.

What was the dispute about?

The appeal concerned an agreement made in March 2017 under which Replay Destinations (Bahamas) Ltd agreed to sell an apartment unit on Paradise Island to Royal Ltd. The unit was to be built incorporating the purchaser’s design plans, making the agreement a design-and-build contract rather than a straightforward sale of land.

Royal paid a deposit of US$774,590.53. It later assigned its contractual rights to Ocean Club Luxury Estates Ltd. The dispute arose after difficulties over the final design plans and the measurements needed for the construction work.

Replay said Royal had failed to provide properly coordinated final design plans. Royal, in turn, alleged that Replay had failed to verify the onsite measurements. The central question before the Privy Council was whether Replay could retain the deposit after terminating the agreement, despite the finding that Replay had also breached the contract.

Why were both parties in breach?

The Supreme Court of the Bahamas found that both parties had failed to comply with their contractual obligations. Replay had not verified the onsite measurements, while Royal had not provided the final design plans based on the corrected measurements.

Those findings were important to the appeal. In an earlier judgment given on 13 December 2025, the Privy Council had determined that the finding of Replay’s breach was a concurrent finding of fact and could not be challenged before the Board in the absence of exceptional circumstances.

The purchaser had also not challenged the finding that it was in breach by failing to provide the final plans when the matter went to the Court of Appeal. It could not use the present appeal to argue that its failure was excused by Replay’s breach or that verification of the measurements was a condition precedent to providing the plans.

  1. Replay and Royal entered into the apartment sale and design-and-build agreement.
  2. Replay served a default notice requiring Royal to deliver coordinated final design plans within ten days.
  3. Replay issued a termination notice and retained the deposit.
  4. Royal served its own notice requiring Replay to comply with its contractual obligations.
  5. The Supreme Court of the Bahamas found both parties in breach and ordered the deposit to be returned.
  6. The Court of Appeal upheld the decision.
  7. The Privy Council allowed Replay’s appeal.

What did the Privy Council decide?

Giving the judgment of the Board, Lord Burrows said that the appeal was confined to the interpretation of clauses 14 and 15 of the contract and whether Replay could rely on clause 14 despite its own breach.

Clause 14, headed “Seller’s Remedies”, allowed the seller to give the purchaser written notice requiring it to comply with its obligations within ten days. If the purchaser did not comply, the seller could terminate the agreement. Subject to applicable law, the seller could then retain the deposit as liquidated damages and as its sole remedy.

The Board found no express requirement in clause 14 that Replay must itself be free from breach before it could serve a valid default notice and termination notice. Royal’s failure to provide the final design plans was a repudiatory breach, and Replay had validly terminated the agreement under the clause.

“An unaccepted repudiation is a thing writ in water and of no value to anybody: it confers no legal rights of any sort or kind.”

— Lord Burrows referring to the statement of Asquith LJ in Howard v Pickford Tool Co Ltd

The Board explained that, as a general rule, a party is not prevented from terminating a contract because it is itself in repudiatory breach. The position may be different where that party’s performance is a condition precedent to the other party’s obligation, but that was not the effect of the relevant contractual wording in this case.

Why did the purchaser not recover the deposit?

The Board distinguished between the remedies available to the seller under clause 14 and those available to the purchaser under clause 15.

Unlike clause 14, clause 15 expressly stated that the purchaser could give a default notice only where the seller failed to comply with the agreement and “Purchaser has complied therewith”. Royal could not satisfy that requirement because it was itself in breach by failing to provide the final design plans.

There was a further difficulty for Royal: its notice to Replay was served on 6 December 2018, after Replay had already terminated the agreement. Royal also did not go on to serve a termination notice under clause 15.

The Board therefore concluded that Royal had no right under clause 15 to demand repayment of the deposit. Clause 14, by contrast, entitled Replay to retain it as the contractual remedy for Royal’s breach.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Frequently asked questions

Can a party terminate a contract if it is also in breach?

Generally, yes. The Privy Council said that a party may terminate for the other party’s established repudiatory breach despite its own breach, unless its own performance is a condition precedent to the other party’s obligation or the contract provides otherwise.

Why was Replay allowed to keep the deposit?

Clause 14 allowed Replay to terminate after Royal failed to provide the final design plans following a default notice. The clause entitled the seller to retain the deposit as its sole remedy, subject to applicable law.

Why could Royal not rely on clause 15?

Clause 15 required the purchaser to have complied with its own contractual obligations. Royal was found to be in breach because it had not provided the final design plans. Its later notice was also served after the agreement had already been terminated.

What does “subject to applicable law” mean in this judgment?

The Board held that the phrase qualified the consequences of termination, rather than the seller’s right to terminate. It left open whether the wording might concern equitable relief against forfeiture or liabilities that cannot lawfully be excluded.

When was the judgment handed down?

The Privy Council handed down its judgment on 19 November 2026, following a hearing on 27 October 2026.

Don’t Miss Key Legal Updates

Get SRA rule changes, SDT decisions, and legal industry news straight to your inbox.
Latest news
Related news