ARU Recruitment Case: High Court Upholds Refusal of Six Care Worker Sponsorship Certificates

Care provider ARU Recruitment Limited has lost its High Court challenge to the Home Office’s refusal to issue six Defined Certificates of Sponsorship for overseas home carers. The judgment examines the evidence employers must provide when seeking to sponsor additional workers and the extent to which the Home Office can ask for further material before deciding whether a staffing need is genuine and credible.

What did the High Court decide?

In R (on the application of ARU Recruitment Limited) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] EWHC 2878 (Admin), handed down on 13 November 2026, Clare Padley, sitting as a Deputy Judge of the High Court, dismissed the claim for judicial review.

ARU Recruitment, which trades as ARU Homecare, challenged the Home Office’s decision of 8 April 2025 refusing its application for six DCoS for care workers. The company argued that the decision-making process was irrational, that the Secretary of State had failed to make appropriate enquiries into employment arrangements in the care sector, and that the Home Office had demanded evidence beyond its published sponsor guidance.

The judge concluded that the Home Office was entitled to seek further evidence to establish whether the six additional roles were genuinely required. The company had not supplied the requested supplementary information, and the refusal was rational and consistent with the published sponsor guidance.

Why were six certificates requested?

ARU Recruitment provides regulated home care services in the East Riding of Yorkshire and had held a Skilled Worker sponsor licence since 7 March 2022. In March 2025, it sought six additional DCoS for home carers, each at an annual salary of £25,350 for 37.5 hours per week.

The company relied principally on a Closed Framework Agreement with East Riding of Yorkshire Council for the provision of domiciliary care services. The agreement ran from 1 April 2025 to 31 March 2027, with provision for further extensions, and covered four geographical lots for which the company had been appointed.

Its application also included a hierarchy chart identifying six healthcare worker vacancies, employment contracts, business bank statements and financial accounts. The company said the council agreement demonstrated a binding commitment and a guaranteed workload requiring additional staff.

However, the framework agreement established the terms under which later call-off contracts could be awarded. It did not itself allocate a fixed number of service users or guarantee a particular quantity of care work.

Why did the Home Office refuse the application?

After the company resubmitted its application on 28 March 2025, the Home Office wrote on 1 April requesting further information. It asked for evidence explaining what each proposed role would involve, the genuine need for the vacancies and how the roles had arisen.

The Home Office gave examples of material that could assist, including additional signed contracts, evidence of business expansion, the opening of new premises, or evidence that employees in the relevant roles had left and needed replacing. It also asked the company to identify relevant contractual provisions, guaranteed hours, service users and work locations where contracts were relied upon.

ARU Recruitment’s solicitors responded on 2 April by challenging the request and asking for urgent reconsideration. The company did not provide the additional evidence sought.

On 8 April 2025, the Home Office refused the application. It said it could not determine how many positions were available because the evidence did not establish the assignments the proposed workers would undertake or the number of vacant working hours. The framework agreement did not specify the number of service users or hours required, and no supplementary information had been supplied to establish the number of vacancies.

The judge noted that the framework agreement did not guarantee work or income. The documents before the Home Office also did not show that ARU Recruitment had been awarded, or had applied for, any call-off contracts under the framework. The agreement therefore did not, by itself, demonstrate the guaranteed workload asserted in the company’s covering letter.

Why was the Hartford case distinguished?

ARU Recruitment relied on R (Hartford Care Group Ltd) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2024] EWHC 3308 (Admin), in which the High Court had allowed a challenge to the refusal of an application for 70 DCoS.

In Hartford, the Home Office had required contracts containing guaranteed hours for specific service users, even though the judge found that such contracts did not exist as standard in the care sector. The evidential requirement was held to be impossible or to have little bearing on whether genuine vacancies existed.

Deputy Judge Padley identified significant differences. In ARU Recruitment’s case, the Home Office did not dispute that the vacancies were genuine. Nor did it rely solely or principally on the absence of specific service-user numbers and hours in the framework agreement. Most importantly, the Home Office had not imposed an impossible evidential requirement.

The 1 April request gave examples of possible evidence but was not confined to a particular form of contract. It expressly invited evidence of business expansion and increased staffing needs. The judge considered that such material could reasonably have been provided, particularly because the company’s own documents referred to planning, budgeting and anticipated growth.

The court therefore found that Hartford was distinguishable on its facts and did not establish that the Home Office’s approach in this case was unlawful.

What does the judgment mean for sponsors?

The decision underlines the importance of matching the number of DCoS requested to evidence of a credible staffing requirement at the relevant time or in the near future. A sponsor may rely on anticipated work, but it must provide material capable of showing why the proposed roles are needed and how the business expects that work to arise.

Where a framework agreement is relied upon, employers should distinguish between being appointed to a framework and having actually secured work under a call-off contract. A framework that sets terms for future work may not establish a guaranteed volume of services, hours, revenue or vacancies.

The judgment also illustrates the practical importance of responding substantively to a Home Office request for further information. In this case, the company chose to challenge the request rather than provide the additional evidence. The judge held that the Home Office was entitled to take the absence of supplementary material into account when assessing the application.

For sponsors, the key point is not that a particular type of contract must always be produced. It is that the evidence as a whole must credibly explain the need for each requested sponsored position and address the employer’s current circumstances and anticipated work.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Frequently asked questions

What did the High Court decide in ARU Recruitment v SSHD?

The High Court dismissed ARU Recruitment’s judicial review claim and upheld the lawfulness of the Home Office’s refusal of its application for six Defined Certificates of Sponsorship.

Why were the six DCoS refused?

The Home Office was unable to determine the number of available positions from the evidence supplied. The framework agreement did not guarantee a fixed workload, service-user numbers or working hours, and the company did not provide the supplementary evidence requested.

Did the court find that care providers cannot rely on framework agreements?

No. The judgment does not establish a blanket rule against relying on framework agreements. It considered the particular agreement and evidence in this case, including the absence of awarded or applied-for call-off contracts and supplementary evidence of the claimed staffing need.

How did this case differ from Hartford Care Group?

The judge found that the Home Office had not imposed an impossible requirement for contracts guaranteeing specific hours for named service users. It had invited a wider range of evidence, including evidence of business expansion, which the company did not provide.

What should employers provide when applying for additional DCoS?

Employers should provide a clear and credible explanation of the number of roles sought, supported by evidence of current or anticipated work, staffing requirements, business plans and relevant contracts or agreements. The appropriate evidence will depend on the circumstances of the application.

Can the Home Office request further information about a DCoS application?

Yes. The judgment confirms that the Home Office may seek further information where it needs to assess whether the requested number of sponsored positions is justified and credible under the published sponsor guidance.

Don’t Miss Key Legal Updates

Get SRA rule changes, SDT decisions, and legal industry news straight to your inbox.
Latest news
Related news