A consumer who switches on a laptop bought online to check its compatibility can still exercise the statutory right to cancel, the Court of Appeal has ruled. The decision rejects Argos’s argument that activating pre-installed Windows 11 broke a “digital seal” and removed the buyer’s right to a refund.
What did the Court of Appeal decide?
In Dr Ebenezer Adodo v Argos Limited [2026] EWCA Civ 1462, handed down on 13 November 2026, the Court of Appeal unanimously allowed Dr Ebenezer Adodo’s second appeal. Lady Justice Andrews gave the substantive judgment, with which Lord Justice Foxton and Lady Justice King agreed.
The court held that the contract was for the supply of a computer preloaded with an operating system, rather than for the supply of “sealed computer software” within Regulation 28(3)(b) of the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013. Activating the operating system to test the computer’s functionality did not bring the contract within that exception.
Argos was ordered to refund the £379 price of the computer, together with interest starting 14 days after Dr Adodo’s unsuccessful attempt to return it on 5 September 2024. The court did not need to determine his application to adduce fresh evidence.
What happened between Dr Adodo and Argos?
On 31 August 2024, Dr Adodo ordered a Lenovo IdeaPad laptop preloaded with Windows 11 from the Argos website. The laptop cost £379. He also bought a mouse pad for £9.99, paying £388.99 in total, and selected Argos’s click-and-collect service.
After collecting the items, Dr Adodo took the laptop out of its box and switched it on to check whether it met his information-technology requirements. He found compatibility problems with software he used for his work at Leicester University. He also found that the mouse pad was too large for his computer table. He put both items back in their boxes and returned them to Argos on 5 September 2024, seeking a refund.
Argos refused to refund the laptop, relying on its returns terms and the fact that the packaging had been opened and Windows 11 activated. Dr Adodo relied on his statutory cancellation rights under the 2013 Regulations.
- Dr Adodo orders the laptop and mouse pad online for a total of £388.99.
- He collects the items, switches on the laptop and identifies compatibility issues.
- He returns both products and requests a refund; Argos refuses the laptop refund.
- The Court of Appeal hears the second appeal.
- The Court of Appeal allows the appeal and orders a refund of the laptop price with interest.
There had already been an earlier appeal. The District Judge initially accepted Argos’s argument that the transaction was not a distance contract. His Honour Judge Hedley later held that the sale contract had been concluded remotely when Argos confirmed the online order. Dr Adodo was therefore entitled to a refund for the mouse pad, but the judge upheld Argos’s refusal to refund the laptop on the basis that activating Windows 11 had broken a “digital seal”.
What is the sealed-software exception?
Regulation 29 of the 2013 Regulations generally gives a consumer the right to cancel a distance or off-premises contract during the cancellation period without giving a reason. For most sales contracts, the period ends 14 days after the day on which the consumer takes physical possession of the goods, subject to the detailed rules in the Regulations.
Regulation 28(3)(b) provides an exception where a contract is for the supply of sealed audio recordings, sealed video recordings or sealed computer software and the goods become unsealed after delivery. The issue in this appeal was whether a laptop supplied with its operating system already installed amounted to a contract for the supply of sealed computer software.
The Court of Appeal considered the wording, context and purpose of the provision, including the consumer-protection objectives of Directive 2011/83/EU. It noted that a consumer who buys remotely should have an opportunity to examine and test goods to the extent necessary to establish their nature, characteristics and functioning, as reflected in Recital 37 of the Directive.
Why did the “digital seal” argument fail?
The court considered that the ordinary meaning of a contract for the supply of “sealed computer software” points to a transaction where the software itself is the object of the sale, supplied on a tangible carrier such as a CD, USB stick or key card in sealed packaging. A customer buying a computer does not ordinarily buy it in order to acquire a copy of its pre-installed operating system. The software is supplied as an incidental feature of the computer and is necessary to make it function.
The judgment also examined the purpose of the exception. The court considered that it is directed principally at protecting intellectual property against copying, and at preventing a consumer from using recordings or software and then returning them as though the retailer were a free lending library. Those concerns may justify preventing the return of separately purchased recordings or software once their physical packaging has been opened.
They did not justify preventing a consumer from activating a laptop’s operating system to test whether the computer works. Argos accepted that stopping a buyer from activating the operating software was unlikely to protect intellectual property rights. The court also rejected the suggestion that the provision should operate as a strict-liability rule simply because the words “not suitable for return” appear in a different exception in Regulation 28(3)(a).
“The ‘seal’ … is a physical seal created by the outer packaging of the tangible medium, and not some notional internal digital barrier to use of the data stored on that medium which is ‘broken’ when the software is activated.”
Lady Justice Andrews, paragraph 74
The court therefore held that Regulation 28(3)(b) must be interpreted strictly and narrowly. It applies where the recording or software is the specific object of the contract and the tangible medium is physically sealed in packaging which the consumer must open to access its contents. It does not apply simply because a computer or another electronic device is supplied with preloaded operating software.
What does Regulation 34 mean for returns?
The judgment distinguishes the right to cancel from a consumer’s possible liability for reducing the value of goods through excessive handling. Under Regulation 34(9), where the value of goods is diminished by handling beyond what is necessary to establish their nature, characteristics and functioning, a trader may recover that amount from the consumer, up to the contract price. Regulation 34(12) explains that handling may go too far where it exceeds what might reasonably be allowed in a shop.
The Commission guidance discussed in the judgment recognises that a consumer may test a computer’s functionality, while configuring software for personal or organisational needs may go beyond what would normally be permitted in a shop. In an appropriate case, reasonable costs of resetting the computer may amount to diminished value.
However, that does not mean the consumer automatically loses the right to cancel. The trader must establish the relevant loss or cost. The Court of Appeal found that no attempt had been made by Argos to establish whether any resetting cost existed or how much it would be. It also did not consider that the findings showed Dr Adodo had configured the preloaded operating software.
What should retailers and consumers know?
For consumers, the decision confirms that switching on an online-purchased computer and activating its pre-installed operating system to test its functionality does not, by itself, remove the statutory cancellation right. The ordinary 14-day cancellation period and the other requirements of the Regulations still need to be considered in each case.
For retailers, standard returns terms cannot narrow statutory cancellation rights. A retailer relying on the sealed-software exception should establish that the contract is genuinely for the supply of the software itself and that the relevant tangible medium was physically sealed. A claim for diminished value due to excessive handling should be supported by evidence of the loss or reasonable resetting costs, rather than treated as an automatic bar to cancellation.
The decision is also a reminder that consumers buying remotely must be given a meaningful opportunity to assess whether goods meet their needs. The Court of Appeal considered that Argos’s proposed interpretation would deprive consumers of the right to cancel almost any online purchase of a computer, phone or similar electronic device once it was switched on, undermining the protection intended by the Regulations.
Frequently asked questions
Can I return a laptop bought online after switching it on?
Switching on a laptop and activating its pre-installed operating system to test its functionality does not, by itself, remove the statutory right to cancel under the 2013 Regulations. The consumer must still comply with the applicable cancellation period and procedure.
What does Regulation 28(3)(b) cover?
It covers contracts for the supply of sealed audio recordings, sealed video recordings or sealed computer software where the goods become unsealed after delivery. The Court of Appeal held that the exception concerns the software or recording itself as the object of the contract and a physical seal on the tangible carrier’s packaging.
Does activating Windows count as breaking a digital seal?
Not for the purpose of the sealed-software exception where Windows is pre-installed on a computer bought as a computer. The Court of Appeal rejected the argument that activating the operating system creates a legally relevant digital seal.
Can a retailer deduct money if a consumer has used the goods?
Potentially. Under Regulation 34, a trader may recover proven diminished value caused by handling beyond what is necessary to establish the goods’ nature, characteristics and functioning. This does not automatically remove the consumer’s right to cancel.
What was the outcome in Adodo v Argos?
The Court of Appeal unanimously allowed Dr Adodo’s appeal and ordered Argos to refund the £379 price of the computer, with interest starting 14 days after his unsuccessful return attempt on 5 September 2024.