The Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) has quashed the conviction of former Deutsche Bank employee Christian Bittar, who pleaded guilty to conspiracy to defraud over alleged manipulation of the Euro Interbank Offered Rate (EURIBOR) between 2005 and 2009.
What did the Court of Appeal decide?
In Christian Bittar v The King [2026] EWCA Crim 1458, handed down on 13 November 2026, the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) quashed Mr Bittar’s conviction for conspiracy to defraud. The judgment records that the court had announced on 9 October 2026 that the conviction would be quashed, with its reasons to follow.
The appeal was allowed on the first ground: that the guilty plea was unsafe because it had been entered in circumstances shaped by a fundamental error in the legal understanding of falsity in the EURIBOR cases. The court granted the necessary extension of time and leave to appeal against conviction.
The court declined to determine the second ground, which argued that the indictment was bad in law because the alleged conspiracy relied on a breach of the EURIBOR code. Having quashed the conviction on the first ground, it said that further consideration of the second was unnecessary.
What was the EURIBOR prosecution about?
Mr Bittar was an employee of Deutsche Bank. The indictment alleged that, between 1 January 2005 and 31 December 2009, he and other individuals associated with Deutsche Bank, Barclays Bank and other financial institutions conspired to defraud by procuring or making false or misleading submissions into the EURIBOR setting process.
The prosecution alleged that the submissions were intended to create an advantage for the trading positions of employees at the relevant banks and deliberately disregarded the proper basis for submitting rates, with the intention that the economic interests of others might be prejudiced.
Mr Bittar pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to defraud at Southwark Crown Court on 2 March 2018, before HHJ Gledhill KC. On 19 July 2018, he was sentenced to five years and four months’ imprisonment. The court also records a prosecution costs order of £799,957 and a confiscation order of £2.5 million under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. The judgment further notes the consequences of the conviction, including deportation to France and a Financial Conduct Authority prohibition order preventing him from working in financial services in the UK.
Why did Mr Bittar plead guilty?
Mr Bittar’s appeal argued that his plea was entered because the legal position, as it was then understood, left him without a realistic opportunity to contest an essential part of the prosecution case. The argument centred on the meaning of “falsity” in the EURIBOR submissions and the effect of earlier rulings on how a jury would be directed.
In September 2017, HHJ Gledhill KC ruled that Article 6 of the EURIBOR code, interpreted according to Belgian law, prohibited panel banks from making submissions intended to create an advantage for their own or another bank’s trading positions. The Court of Appeal affirmed that ruling in R v B [2018] EWCA Crim 73.
Mr Bittar’s legal team was concerned that the approach taken in earlier LIBOR proceedings would be followed in the EURIBOR trial: that requests for particular rates would effectively lead to a conclusion that the rates submitted were false. The defence maintained that this would prevent a jury from properly considering whether the rates submitted were genuinely believed to fall within a range that could reasonably be submitted.
The court considered evidence from members of Mr Bittar’s former defence team. Their evidence was that they believed the anticipated directions would make the defence extremely difficult and that the jury would likely conclude that the conduct was dishonest without the prosecution having to prove the relevant issue of falsity.
Why did the court find the conviction unsafe?
The Court of Appeal considered the principles governing appeals following guilty pleas, including the approach in R v Tredget [2022] EWCA Crim 108, R v Kakaei [2021] EWCA Crim 503 and R v Bani [2021] EWCA Crim 1958. Those authorities recognise that a conviction may be quashed where a guilty plea was effectively compelled by an adverse legal ruling that removed an arguable defence.
The court distinguished between a ruling that makes a defence more difficult, even almost hopeless, and one that leaves no arguable defence to put before a jury. It concluded that Mr Bittar’s position was exceptional because the issue he wished to contest would not have been left to the jury as a result of a ruling in an earlier case, which he could not directly challenge in his own proceedings.
“The facts of this case are even more ‘striking’ than those in Bani.”
The court emphasised that Mr Bittar’s plea did not necessarily amount to an admission that the rate submissions were false. He was prepared to concede that procuring submissions in deliberate disregard of the EURIBOR code was dishonest, but that did not automatically establish that he had submitted rates he knew to be false.
In the court’s view, the combination of earlier judicial rulings and the legal advice given to Mr Bittar meant that an issue capable of resulting in acquittal would not be left to the jury. In those particular circumstances, the conviction was no safer than convictions in the related cases that had been quashed after juries were misdirected.
What are the consequences of the ruling?
The conviction has been quashed. The judgment records the substantial consequences that had followed from it, including the custodial sentence, confiscation order, prosecution costs, deportation and FCA prohibition. The judgment does not itself set out a detailed mechanism or timetable for resolving every consequential matter.
The court also considered a claim for interest on sums due to be repaid following the quashing of convictions. It declined to make an award of interest in Mr Bittar’s case, applying the reasons given in a judgment handed down at the same time on that issue.
The decision forms part of the wider sequence of appeals arising from the LIBOR and EURIBOR benchmark manipulation prosecutions, following the Supreme Court’s judgment in R v Hayes & Palombo [2025] UKSC 29 and subsequent Court of Appeal decisions quashing related convictions.
Key dates in the proceedings
- Period covered by the alleged EURIBOR conspiracy
- HHJ Gledhill KC rules on the interpretation of Article 6 of the EURIBOR code
- Court of Appeal affirms the ruling in R v B [2018] EWCA Crim 73
- Mr Bittar pleads guilty to conspiracy to defraud
- Sentenced to five years and four months’ imprisonment
- Supreme Court gives judgment in R v Hayes & Palombo [2025] UKSC 29
- Court of Appeal announces that Mr Bittar’s conviction will be quashed
- Approved judgment setting out the reasons is handed down
Frequently asked questions
Why was Christian Bittar’s conviction quashed?
The Court of Appeal concluded that his guilty plea was entered in circumstances where an important issue about whether the EURIBOR rate submissions were false would not have been left to a jury because of earlier legal rulings and the advice based on them.
Was Mr Bittar convicted after a trial?
No. He pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to defraud at Southwark Crown Court on 2 March 2018.
What sentence had Mr Bittar received?
He was sentenced on 19 July 2018 to five years and four months’ imprisonment. The judgment also records a £2.5 million confiscation order and prosecution costs of £799,957.
Did the Court of Appeal decide whether the indictment was legally defective?
No. The court declined to determine that separate ground because it had already decided to quash the conviction on the first ground of appeal.
Did the court award interest on sums to be repaid?
No. The court declined to make an award of interest in Mr Bittar’s case, for the reasons given in a judgment handed down at the same time on that issue.