R v Alex Pabon and Others: Court of Appeal Rules on Interest After Quashed Convictions

The Court of Appeal has ruled that it cannot itself award interest on prosecution-cost and confiscation payments following the quashing of convictions in a series of high-profile LIBOR and EURIBOR cases, but said the authorities should honour an earlier commitment to pay.

What did the Court of Appeal decide?

In R v Alex Pabon and others [2026] EWCA Crim 1457, handed down on 13 November 2026, the Court of Appeal Criminal Division considered whether it could order interest on sums to be repaid after confiscation orders and prosecution-cost orders fell away following the quashing of the appellants’ convictions.

The court declined to make the requested award. It concluded that its statutory and implied powers did not extend to deciding a claim for interest on the debts or repayments in question. Such a claim, if pursued, would be more appropriately determined by a civil court.

However, the court also addressed the position reached by the parties before the jurisdictional issue was raised. The SFO and HMCTS had agreed an order which included interest on the same basis as the order made by the Supreme Court in the related Hayes and Palombo appeals. The Court of Appeal considered that fairness required those agencies to honour that commitment.

What were the LIBOR and EURIBOR appeals about?

The judgment arose from five references made by the Criminal Cases Review Commission on 29 January 2026. The appellants had been convicted of conspiracy to defraud in cases concerning alleged manipulation of benchmark interest rates.

Alex Pabon, Jay Vijay Merchant and Jonathan Mathew had been convicted in relation to alleged manipulation of LIBOR. The EURIBOR-related cases included Philippe Moryoussef and Colin Bermingham. The Court of Appeal had quashed the relevant convictions on 7 October 2026, giving reasons at that stage. This later judgment dealt with consequential financial issues rather than the safety of the convictions themselves.

The five references were heard together, but the interest application in this judgment was made by the appellants named in its title. The court noted that Mr Moryoussef did not apply for an order for costs or interest.

  1. The first three LIBOR-related appellants were convicted following trial.
  2. Philippe Moryoussef was convicted in the EURIBOR proceedings.
  3. Colin Bermingham was convicted at a retrial.
  4. The Criminal Cases Review Commission referred five cases to the Court of Appeal.
  5. The Court of Appeal quashed the convictions.
  6. The court handed down its judgment on the consequential interest issue.

Why was interest disputed?

When the convictions were quashed, the confiscation orders and prosecution-cost orders based on them also fell away. Sums paid under those orders were therefore to be repaid. The disagreement concerned whether the repayments should include interest for the period during which the appellants had been deprived of the money.

The appellants relied on principles of restitution and authorities including Nykredit Mortgage Bank v Edward Erman, Delta Petroleum (Caribbean) Ltd v British Virgin Islands Electricity Corporation and Evonik UK Holdings v HMRC. Their case was that interest could be required to give full effect to a successful appeal and reverse the financial effects of orders that should not have stood.

The issue had also arisen in the Supreme Court’s earlier decision in R v Hayes; R v Palombo [2025] UKSC 29. In that case, the Supreme Court ordered interest on sums repaid following the quashing of confiscation and prosecution-cost orders. The rate was set at 2% per annum up to and including 31 December 2021, and 5% per annum thereafter, compounded with yearly rests.

In the present appeals, the parties initially presented an agreed consequential order that replicated the approach in Hayes and Palombo. The court then asked them to address whether the Criminal Division had the power to make such an order, given that the Supreme Court Rules expressly provide for interest orders and there is no equivalent express provision for the Court of Appeal Criminal Division.

Why did the court say it lacked jurisdiction?

The court examined the statutory powers of the Criminal Division, including the Criminal Appeal Act 1968. It noted that the court can quash convictions and make certain orders concerning sentences, costs and confiscation, but has no express general power to compensate people for the adverse consequences of a conviction that is later quashed.

The judgment distinguished between the repayment of money and the award of interest. The appellants’ right to recover sums paid under the quashed orders was not in dispute. The court explained that, if repayment were not made when due, a claim to recover the debt could be brought in the civil courts. It considered that any dispute about interest on that debt should also be resolved in that forum.

The court accepted that civil courts may have powers to award interest in restitutionary or debt proceedings. But it rejected the argument that those powers were implicitly available to the Criminal Division, which does not itself determine ordinary contractual claims or claims for the recovery of debt.

“The interest being sought can be sought in civil proceedings, if it is due at all.”

— Court of Appeal, paragraph 36

The court also considered the Supreme Court’s earlier order in Hayes and Palombo. It was not satisfied that the Supreme Court’s decision established that the Criminal Division had the same power. The Supreme Court Rules contain an express provision permitting the Supreme Court to order interest on an appeal; the Court of Appeal’s rules do not contain an equivalent provision.

What happens to the interest claim?

Although the court concluded that it had no jurisdiction to make the requested interest order, it considered the practical and fairness implications of the parties’ earlier agreement. It said it would be obviously unfair if Mr Bermingham were denied interest that Mr Palombo had received after being convicted in the same trial on the same evidence. It also recognised the connection between the other appellants and the related Hayes and Palombo cases.

The court observed that its intervention had prompted HMCTS and the SFO to withdraw from their earlier position on interest. That intervention had been intended to clarify the jurisdictional position for future cases, rather than to produce different treatment for appellants in closely related circumstances.

In those circumstances, the court considered that fairness required HMCTS and the SFO to honour the commitment they had made when the agreed order was prepared. It said there was no merit in requiring the appellants to start fresh civil proceedings if the agencies were satisfied that the interest should be paid in the circumstances.

The formal conclusion was that the court declined to award interest, while expressing the hope that the issue would not require further litigation. The judgment therefore does not itself make an enforceable interest award or determine every issue that might arise in any civil claim.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Frequently asked questions

Did the Court of Appeal quash the convictions in this judgment?

The convictions had already been quashed on 7 October 2026. The judgment dated 13 November 2026 dealt with the consequential issue of interest on sums repayable following the quashing of the orders.

Did the Court of Appeal award interest?

No. It declined to make a formal award because it considered that the Criminal Division did not have jurisdiction to determine the interest claim in these proceedings.

Can the appellants still seek interest?

The judgment states that an interest claim, if due, may be pursued in the civil courts. It also says that fairness required HMCTS and the SFO to honour the commitment to pay interest that they had made.

What interest rate was discussed?

The agreed approach replicated the Supreme Court order in Hayes and Palombo: 2% per annum up to and including 31 December 2021, then 5% per annum, compounded with yearly rests. The Court of Appeal did not itself make an award at those rates.

Which cases were involved?

The references concerned convictions arising from alleged manipulation of LIBOR and EURIBOR. The appellants named in this consequential judgment were Alex Pabon, Jay Vijay Merchant, Jonathan Mathew and Colin Bermingham.

Don’t Miss Key Legal Updates

Get SRA rule changes, SDT decisions, and legal industry news straight to your inbox.
Latest news
Related news