High Court Quashes Refusal of Afghan ARAP Application Over Procedural Unfairness

The High Court has quashed a decision refusing an Afghan national assistance under the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy, finding that the process was unfair because the applicant was not told that an eligibility issue he believed had been resolved remained under reconsideration.

What did the High Court decide?

In BVD v Secretary of State for Defence [2026] EWHC 2990 (Admin), handed down on 18 November 2026, Mr Justice Johnson allowed BVD’s claim for judicial review. The challenge concerned a decision dated 24 June 2026 refusing his application under Category 4 of ARAP.

The court held that the procedure leading to that refusal was unfair. Before the final reconsideration, BVD had expressly told the Secretary of State that he understood Condition 1 to be no longer in dispute and that his further representations would therefore focus on Conditions 2 and 3. The decision-maker nevertheless reconsidered Condition 1 and refused the application on the basis that it was not met, without first correcting BVD’s misunderstanding or inviting further submissions on that issue.

The court did not decide whether the refusal was also irrational. Having found the process unfair and quashed the decision, Mr Justice Johnson considered it unnecessary to determine the rationality ground.

What is ARAP and what does Condition 1 require?

ARAP provides for assistance to certain people who worked in Afghanistan alongside a UK Government department and who meet specified conditions. The case concerned the fourth category of eligibility.

As set out in the judgment, the relevant criteria required an applicant to have:

  • Condition 1: worked in Afghanistan alongside a UK Government department, in partnership with or closely supporting and assisting that department;
  • Condition 2: made a substantive and positive contribution, in the course of that work, to the UK’s military objectives or national security objectives with respect to Afghanistan; and
  • Condition 3: been at an elevated risk of targeted attacks because of that work.

Eligibility decisions were made by the Defence Afghan Relocation and Resettlement team (DARR) within the Ministry of Defence. BVD’s challenge arose after the authorities changed their position on whether his work met Condition 1.

How did the application and earlier decisions progress?

BVD, an Afghan national, had worked as a civil servant in Afghanistan for approximately 15 years. He said that his work involved contact with foreign government officials, including the UK Department for International Development (DFID), and that some projects on which he worked were partly funded by DFID. He applied under ARAP on 24 August 2021, after the Taliban takeover.

  1. BVD submits an ARAP application, relying on roles undertaken during his Afghan civil service employment.
  2. DARR refuses the application under Category 4, finding that Condition 1 is not satisfied.
  3. Following a request for review and earlier proceedings, DARR again refuses the application on Condition 1 grounds.
  4. After further proceedings and information from the FCDO, DARR accepts that Condition 1 is met but refuses the application because it considers Condition 2 unmet.
  5. BVD issues the present judicial review claim challenging the decision of 23 July 2025.
  6. BVD provides further representations, expressly proceeding on the basis that Condition 1 is no longer in dispute and addressing Conditions 2 and 3.
  7. DARR refuses the application again, this time concluding that Condition 1 is not met.
  8. The High Court allows the judicial review claim and quashes the refusal for procedural unfairness.

The earlier decision of 23 July 2025 had recorded that BVD met Condition 1 after the FCDO concluded there was sufficient evidence of his role in support of a programme and his engagement with its governance. That decision was later withdrawn so that the application could be reconsidered.

Why was the reconsideration process unfair?

The Secretary of State argued that the July 2025 decision had been withdrawn in full. The fresh assessment was therefore not bound by its earlier favourable conclusion on Condition 1 and could reconsider the application as a whole. Mr Justice Johnson accepted that argument as a matter of decision-making power: the earlier finding did not have to be preserved, and the reconsideration was not legally confined to Condition 2.

However, the court distinguished the Secretary of State’s power to reconsider the issue from the fairness of the way that power was exercised. BVD’s solicitors had stated in their representations of 22 May 2026 that Condition 1 was no longer in dispute. They explained that the further submissions would focus on Conditions 2 and 3. The Secretary of State therefore knew that BVD was deliberately not advancing further evidence or arguments on Condition 1 because he believed it had already been resolved in his favour.

The judge considered that understanding understandable in the circumstances. The earlier fresh decision had accepted Condition 1 in unqualified terms, and the dispute that led to the withdrawal of that decision had centred on Condition 2. No material new adverse evidence concerning Condition 1 had been identified to BVD.

“The Secretary of State ought to have told BVD that he was mistaken, that Condition 1 remained in issue”

Mr Justice Johnson, [2026] EWHC 2990 (Admin)

The court did not require the Secretary of State to disclose every provisional concern or to invite a response to each evidential point. A short communication explaining that Condition 1 remained under reconsideration, warning that a different conclusion might be reached and inviting any further representations would have been sufficient.

That step was particularly important because Condition 1 ultimately became the determinative issue. By failing to correct the misunderstanding, the Secretary of State denied BVD a fair opportunity to address the basis on which his application was to be refused.

The consequences of the decision also mattered. The application concerned the possible relocation of BVD and his family from circumstances in which they said they faced grave risks. The judgment noted that the ARAP scheme had closed to new principal applicants, meaning BVD could not remedy the position by submitting a fresh application. In that context, the loss of an opportunity to make representations was capable of causing substantial and irreversible prejudice.

What relief did the court order?

The judicial review claim succeeded on procedural fairness. The court quashed the decision of 24 June 2026 and required the Secretary of State to make a fresh decision.

Before doing so, the Secretary of State must give BVD a reasonable opportunity to provide further evidence and representations concerning all applicable ARAP conditions and must take that material into account. The judge directed that the representations be provided and the fresh decision made as soon as practicable.

However, the court declined to make the mandatory and declaratory orders sought by BVD. It had not been shown that the only lawful outcome would be a decision in his favour. The appropriate remedy was therefore to quash the refusal and remit the application for reconsideration, rather than declare him eligible for ARAP assistance.

What does the judgment mean for public decision-makers?

The judgment illustrates the distinction between the scope of an administrative decision-maker’s legal powers and the procedural fairness required when those powers are exercised. A public authority may be entitled to reopen an issue as part of a fresh decision, but that does not remove the need to ensure that an affected person has a meaningful opportunity to address a determinative issue in the circumstances of the case.

Where an applicant’s submissions make clear that they are proceeding on a material misunderstanding about what remains in issue, a decision-maker should consider whether that misunderstanding needs to be corrected before reaching an adverse decision. The court indicated that this can be done without providing a running commentary on the assessment or disclosing every evidential concern.

The judgment also underlines the importance of context. The seriousness of the interests affected, the history of earlier decisions, the applicant’s stated understanding and the practical consequences of refusing the application all informed the fairness assessment.

For practitioners advising applicants or public bodies, the case is a reminder to make the scope of any reconsideration clear and to address expressly any apparent misunderstanding before a fresh decision is made.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Frequently asked questions

Did the High Court find that BVD was eligible for ARAP?

No. The court quashed the refusal because the process was unfair, but declined to declare BVD eligible. The application must be reconsidered.

Why was the decision-making process unfair?

BVD had expressly explained that he was not making further submissions on Condition 1 because he understood it was no longer in dispute. The Secretary of State knew of that understanding but did not correct it before Condition 1 was reconsidered and became decisive.

Was the Secretary of State entitled to reconsider Condition 1?

Yes. The earlier decision had been withdrawn in full, and there was no express limitation confining the fresh reconsideration to Condition 2. The Secretary of State could reconsider all applicable conditions, but had to do so through a fair process.

Did the court decide whether the refusal was irrational?

No. Having found procedural unfairness and quashed the decision, the judge considered it unnecessary to determine the separate rationality ground.

What must happen next?

The Secretary of State must give BVD a reasonable opportunity to submit further evidence and representations on all applicable ARAP conditions, consider that material and make a fresh decision as soon as practicable.

Don’t Miss Key Legal Updates

Get SRA rule changes, SDT decisions, and legal industry news straight to your inbox.
Latest news
Related news