Kuwait Social Security Wins Major £? Corruption Case Over $1 Billion Secret Commissions

The High Court has delivered a major judgment in a long-running claim brought by Kuwait’s Public Institution for Social Security over secret commissions connected to the investment of public funds. The decision follows a Commercial Court trial lasting 133 sitting days and examines alleged corruption involving intermediaries, investment managers, banks and offshore financial structures.

What did the High Court decide?

In The Public Institution for Social Security v Muna Al-Rajaan Al-Wazzan and Others [2026] EWHC 2847 (Comm), Mr Justice Jacobs considered claims arising from payments made over a period of around two decades in connection with investments arranged for PIFSS.

PIFSS operates Kuwait’s state social security system, providing insurance for old age, disability, sickness and death. Its funds are invested to generate returns to meet future obligations. Fahad Maziad Al Rajaan served as its Director General from 1984 until his retirement in January 2014, apart from a period of suspension in 2012.

The court found that Mr Al Rajaan used his influence over investment decisions to procure secret commissions for himself and associates. The judgment records that the commissions were arranged without PIFSS’s knowledge or consent and were connected to fees generated by investments and financial services provided to the institution.

The claim against Mr Al Rajaan continued after his death in September 2022 through his estate, represented in the proceedings by his widow. She was also joined personally so that determinations concerning assets nominally held in her name would bind her; the judgment did not make a specific allegation of wrongdoing against her personally.

  • Secret commissions identified USD 1.036bn Approximate total
  • Trial length 133 days Sitting days
  • Director General tenure 30 years 1984 to 2014
  • Judgment handed down 5 Nov 2026 Commercial Court

How did the secret commission schemes operate?

The judgment describes a common pattern across the different arrangements. PIFSS made investments and entered into financial services arrangements under Mr Al Rajaan’s control or influence. Fees were payable in connection with those investments, and a proportion of the fees was then used to fund secret commissions.

Intermediaries were used to present the payments as legitimate rebates, commissions or introduction fees. The court found that the arrangements were structured to conceal the true destination and purpose of the money, including by routing payments through offshore bank accounts and corporate or trust entities.

Some payments passed through companies and personal accounts held in the name of Mr Al Rajaan’s wife, whom the judgment describes as acting as his nominee. The judgment also examined the role of banks and financial institutions in establishing accounts, processing transfers and facilitating the movement of funds.

“The basic facts can be simply explained.”

The judgment nevertheless examined a complex network of transactions, entities and alleged participants across multiple jurisdictions.

The court’s overview places the relevant period at no later than about 1994 until about 2015. It records that the sums arranged as secret commissions were approximately USD 1.036 billion, paid to Mr Al Rajaan, people acting at his direction or parties connected with him.

Which financial schemes were considered?

PIFSS organised its case around a number of schemes. The judge considered them separately while recognising that the financial flows were not always confined to one scheme and that Mr Al Rajaan was a central figure across them.

Principal schemes considered in the judgment
SchemePrincipal focus
MirabaudSecret commissions and related payments associated with investments and accounts connected to Banque Mirabaud.
PictetPayments linked to investment arrangements and intermediaries associated with Banque Pictet.
VPDealings involving Mr Al Rajaan, Mr Nasrallah and accounts associated with VP Bank.
EFGAlleged assistance in laundering and concealing secret commissions and their proceeds.
AeriumProperty-related funds, intermediary commissions and direct payments connected with Ely Michel Ruimy and Aerium Finance.
PenséePayments and asset structures involving the Pensée Foundation and related entities.
ManHedge fund investments and commission payments involving Man group companies and intermediaries.
MombelliCommission arrangements and companies through which Francesco Mombelli operated.

The judgment also addressed the UBP scheme. That part of the dispute no longer required detailed determination following a settlement involving a substantial payment by UBP. Banque Mirabaud and EFG also reached settlements with PIFSS, which affected the amounts potentially recoverable from other parties.

Who was found liable?

In its overall conclusion, the court held that PIFSS’s claim for substantial compensation or related relief succeeded against the following defendants:

  • The estate of Fahad Al Rajaan, represented by the first defendant.
  • Antoine Nasrallah.
  • Man Investments Limited and Man Investments AG.
  • Antoine Massad and Mohamad El Ghazzi.
  • Francesco Mombelli and the other Mombelli defendants.
  • Gilles Guerin.
  • Ely Michel Ruimy and Aerium Finance Limited.
  • The Pensée Foundation.

The judgment also records that Ms Al Wazzan was within the successful claim for declaratory relief. No relief was claimed against Mr Al Rajaan’s heirs, although they were bound by the determinations made in the proceedings, including the finding as to the liability of his estate.

The outcome should be read in the context of the specific findings against each defendant and each scheme. The judgment did not treat every party named in the proceedings as having been found liable. Some banks and individuals had previously succeeded in jurisdictional challenges, while other claims had been settled or remained outside the issues tried.

What happened to the defences and settlements?

The defendants advanced a range of arguments, including that they did not know of any improper payments, that the arrangements were not unauthorised, and that PIFSS’s internal procedures had contributed to the alleged wrongdoing. The court also considered arguments concerning limitation, justiciability, causation and the proper measure of compensation.

The judgment records that there was no evidence that PIFSS had authorised Mr Al Rajaan’s personal interest in the investments. The judge also rejected the contention that the proceedings were an abuse of process motivated by political persecution. He concluded that PIFSS had a legitimate claim and that it was not an abuse of process to pursue it.

Several settlements affected the position. UBP settled during PIFSS’s opening submissions. A settlement with Banque Mirabaud and associated defendants was reached in May 2026, after the trial had concluded. PIFSS and EFG reached a confidential settlement on 17 September 2026. The court explained that the impact of the latter settlements on quantum, together with issues such as the currency of any judgment, would be addressed at a consequential hearing.

Accordingly, the figures discussed in the judgment are not necessarily the final amounts to be reflected in the resulting orders. The court’s liability conclusions and the final calculation of recoverable sums are distinct matters.

Why does the judgment matter?

The decision is significant for claims involving alleged corruption, secret commissions and the movement of investment-related payments through complex international structures. It demonstrates the scale of factual and legal issues that can arise where public investment decisions are alleged to have been influenced by undisclosed personal financial interests.

For financial institutions, fund managers and intermediaries, the judgment highlights the importance of understanding the purpose and beneficial destination of commissions, rebates and introduction fees, as well as the risks associated with opaque payment routes and offshore structures.

For litigators, the case is also notable for its treatment of foreign law, private international law, limitation, justiciability, recoveries and the assessment of claims arising from conduct spanning multiple jurisdictions. The court’s conclusions followed an exceptionally lengthy trial and a detailed examination of the evidence relating to each scheme.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Frequently asked questions

What is PIFSS?

The Public Institution for Social Security operates Kuwait’s state social security system, providing insurance for old age, disability, sickness and death. It invests funds to help meet future obligations.

How much was involved in the alleged secret commissions?

The judgment describes secret commissions of approximately USD 1.036 billion arranged between about 1994 and 2015 for Mr Al Rajaan, people acting at his direction or connected parties.

Who handed down the judgment?

Mr Justice Jacobs handed down the judgment in the High Court of Justice, Business and Property Courts, Commercial Court, on 5 November 2026.

Did the court find every defendant liable?

No. The court identified the defendants against whom PIFSS’s claim succeeded in its overall conclusion. Other parties had settled, succeeded in jurisdictional challenges, or were not the subject of a liability finding in this trial.

Has the final compensation amount been determined?

The judgment sets out liability conclusions and discusses quantum, but it explains that the impact of certain settlements and other consequential matters would be addressed at a later hearing. The figures in the judgment therefore should not be treated as the final amounts payable under the resulting orders.

Why was the trial notable?

The Commercial Court described it as the longest Commercial Court trial for 20 years, occupying approximately 133 sitting days, excluding reading days.

Don’t Miss Key Legal Updates

Get SRA rule changes, SDT decisions, and legal industry news straight to your inbox.
Latest news
Related news